Close

Design Consideration 1

A project log for Hable

This project is inspired by the previous work Tipo : Braille Smartphone Keypad on Hackaday.

ayushman-talwarAyushman Talwar 12/02/2018 at 15:070 Comments

WIRED v/s WIRELESS HID (Human Interface Device)

This post is going to discuss the decision to use Bluetooth HID over other communications. 

1. User Experience

Bluetooth interface saves the user from switching cables. Wired communication method would use the same USB port as the charging cable. Using power charging cables is considered to be poor user experience.   

2. Design  

Wired HID cannot be adopted on all phone types. Since not all smartphones have standard placement of USB socket, the keyboard should be able to adapt to the phone type. Wired communication also obstructs user's interaction with the smartphone/keypad. 

3. Manufacturing 

Wired HID would require separate USB type for each phone type. Having multiple USB types for the same device will increase manufacturing complexity and cost of capital.

These are 3 major influencing factors to select wireless communication.

Discussions