So it started when I replied to a comment (that itself replies to me talking about this project):
Trying to set up a simulation
I was thinking that it would be as simple as setting up an electronic cooling simulation in Fusion360:
But then I go to solve and:
Thus, I started looking around for another solution.
Trimming down the mass of the hotend
Trying ElmerSolver in FreeCAD
The main one I stumbled on was ElmerSolver in FreeCAD:
I soon realised that Elmer was the software I was looking into for Tetrinsic too. Anyway, I imported the .step into FreeCAD and noticed that it looked slightly longer:
I decided to move on from that mildly interesting observation and start messing around with features until something exploded:
Looking for other solutions
- There's Simscale but it seems that the free teir only gets 10 solves and there was no mention that they reset after a certain amount of time.
- There's OpenFOAM and I'll have to look into that, since FreeCAD supports that too.
- There is Simflow that is based on OpenFOAM that seems to have a very nice-sounding free tier
Further design optimisations
I asked Elelven about any price reduction strategies and she, once again, suggested to skip on the tapped threads:
I thought that it would be a good idea to actually modell the important threads into the part, which are all the M8x1 threads and the M6x1 thread at the bottom. I watched the first strategy in the below video and looked at comments, and decided to offset the faces by the equations below the video.
tol = 0.3mm Angled Faces Offset: -tol / 4 Vertical Faces Offset: -tol / 2
Lastly, I deleted the bottom-most face so that there wouldn't be a 90 degree overhang where the thread meets the internal chamfer:
Then I did the M6:
Then I could do some more DeleteFaces magic to obtain this:
Lastly, I pushed the below face down to save around another 3 grams. The result is that the autoquote is now $167.17, over $20 lower than the first version I sent to PCBway.
[08:40] I just got the price and it's a whole $194.00, so the additional cost for tapped threads is likely the similar $30-ish that I experienced back when I designed and submitted the printed coaxial heatblock.
[20:40] I also looked at the additional fees involved. Fedex is suprisingly the cheapest option, even lower than others like China Post or PostNL. At an optimistic best, the entire cost is £182, but could be as much as £182 + 20% duty + £12 Fedex fee = £230.
[Jan 05] I found the issue with Fusion360; I needed to change the cloud credic preferences.
I then proceeded to try and set up a thermal study, trying to get over the hurdles along the way:
Then alculated the convection coefficient:
(11.89 * 0.0004719474) / (1092 * 10 ^ -6) = 5.1386946758 m/s 10.45 - 5.13 + 10*sqrt(5.13) = 27.96950330581225 W/m^2-K
And this is the result for a nozzle-cartridge temperature of 250C and coaxial-cartridge temperature of 180C:
As you can see, the heatsink is mostly ineffective.
Discussions
Become a Hackaday.io Member
Create an account to leave a comment. Already have an account? Log In.