Unlike the original simulation, the actual motors are not by themselves in free space and I was wondering if the magnetic field outside the motor was going to cause issues. It does. Below are screenshots in steps of 15 degrees for a rotor with a 17mm centre-to-centre distance:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6a747/6a74780d10e6a3a6a263885f5fe0a09c54b87f63" alt=""
The colours have been capped os that anything over 1000 gauss is purple. I also got torque values and the fluctuation was a very significant: 26.0 +/- 6 mN.m.
I decided to see what "M-22" laminations would be, as mentioned in the BLDC FEMM tutorial, and the difference is massive:
The flux is completely contained and the torque about the rotor is 29.8 mN.m. At least I know that the ferrite toroids can get 87% the torque of proper laminations but leaks a magnetic field.
This is in utter contrast to the stainless steel 304 tube idea:
Discussions
Become a Hackaday.io Member
Create an account to leave a comment. Already have an account? Log In.