Close

Aisler vs. OSHPark comparison

davedarkodavedarko wrote 10/21/2017 at 10:25 • 4 min read • Like

Update 23rd of October

Aisler now offers free shipping!


Please keep in mind that I was able to participate in some test runs and beta tests, some anecdotes are hidden in this write up. They're definitely safe to try out :)

I've met @Felix Plitzko at the MakerFaire Hannover this year and we've talked about boards that AISLER has already made for the company I work for. Felix told me he likes the #LAMEBOY and offered me a free round of boards and a metal stencil to compare. Here is an overview of their service compared to OSH Park. They don't make it a secret that OSH Park is definitely an inspiration. 

OSH ParkAISLER
Prices for shipping
to and buying in Germany
20.24€ * 22.17€ 28.17€ (-6.00€ for shipping)
Boards33
Layer parameters2 (0.8mm, 1.6mm)
4 (1.6mm)
2 (1.6mm)
4 layers in beta
Design Rules6mil trace clearance
6mil trace width
10mil drill size
5mil annular ring
4mil trace clearance
4mil trace width
8mil drill size
10+drill size mil min pad 
color of PCBspurpleolive green  (sadly not orange)
FinishENIGENIG
Design file supporteagle, KiCad, gerbereagle, KiCad, fritzing, gerber
production time12 calendar days + shipping12 days + shipping

*no tolls bc below import tax minimum and with free shipping

The first picture shows a round of the first version of Lameboy, some parts are replaced now or moved or deleted (kind of sad about the steel stencil). I swear I replaced the OSH Park logo on the AISLER boards with an AISLER appropriate text, but I must have mixed files up. You can see a yellow "x- out" sticker, where I currently have no idea what it means, but the board's pads look pretty pierced, may be from electrical testing? The typical "byte marks" on the OSH Park boards (7 here) are sometimes slightly in the board, AISLER gives you a clean bulge.  

As you can see here the OSH Park silkscreen had some issues in this 0.8mm run, the C and RST labels of the buttons aren't printed well, where as the AISLER board is slightly offset to the bottom, so the OFF and ON Lines are cut in. The eyes of the skull look bigger on the AISLER board.

In the second round of the OSH Park boards (as seen on the right of the following image) there are no errors in the silkscreen though.

The stencil of AISLER is looking pretty good, position it right and you can see only gold. 

Overall I'm pretty happy with the quality of the boards since day one, but I also had some bad luck with orders. On my very first run of boards for the company I work for, I had the ground plane peeking out next to every pin, never happened with any other board manufacturer but was my fault and I could have seen it in the high resolution renders on the page. Since then they did a lot of magic to process the boards before they go in production. They seem to constantly update and upgrade their services and product, which is great if you think about it, but it might happen that you get a wild outline or your order of a "non public test run of steel stencils" (!) gets lost in an excel file :D (they don't use excel for that, now that it's public!!) But as with OSH Park the staff is communicative and interested in how they can improve and make it easier for you to make things. They're also in the process of adding PCB assembly to their services. 

Their page gives you version management and the option to change board designs up until manufacturing begins, something that one person or another might miss in OSH Park (although production at OSH Park starts way sooner due to higher demand and a nice mail to support@oshpark.com might fix file problems). If they manage to nail the "order 3 complete prototypes" then AISLER would win the hearts by a lot of people, IMHO. 

Like

Discussions

Felix Plitzko wrote 10/21/2017 at 13:00 point

thanks for the review!

For all readers of this review, I'm Felix from AISLER, so feel free to ask me anything.

  Are you sure? yes | no

davedarko wrote 10/21/2017 at 13:20 point

Sure! I feel a bit bad because it took me a while, but am relieved that I finally did it :) 

  Are you sure? yes | no

Felix Plitzko wrote 10/21/2017 at 13:31 point

Don't be! It's done ;-) No reason to feel bad!

  Are you sure? yes | no