Thanks to Janice, here's a cool recipe for ultrasound gel.
I messed with the recipe awhile and came up with a very nice slightly caramel tinged ultrasound gel this way:
Mix 2 teaspoons of guar gum with 1-2 teaspoons of salt. (The amount of salt isn't vitally important since it is just added to keep the guar gum from clumping. Using slightly less than a teaspoon of salt per 2 cups makes a gel with which is isotonic, which would be ideal for use near eyes or other mucus membranes or on open wounds).
Boil two cups of water.
Slowly sprinkle the guar gum/salt mixture into the boiling water while stirring vigorously with a fork or whisk.
Boil for about 1-2 minutes until thick and well mixed.
"This paper describes design of a low cost, ultrasound gel from local products applying aspects of Human Centered Design methodology. A multidisciplinary team worked with clinicians who use ultrasound where commercial gel is cost prohibitive and scarce. The team followed the format outlined in the Ideo Took Kit. Research began by defining the challenge "how to create locally available alternative ultrasound gel for a low-resourced environment? The "End-Users," were identified as clinicians who use ultrasound in Democratic Republic of the Congo and Ethiopia. An expert group was identified and queried for possible alternatives to commercial gel."
One of the identified issues with current DIY phantoms is that they're essentially made of growth medium (gelatin in water/agar). A well kept standard DIY phantom may last 10 days before it is overcome by mold. This can be enhanced a little bit by wiping it down with bleach (other cleaners appeared to break down the phantom), but it is ultimately a losing battle.
Breakdown is a pretty big issue as the surface of the phantom is critically important. Small, almost invisible imperfections, can cause apparently massive surface artifacts in an ultrasound. Two types of imperfections are really intrusive, but they're ultimately due to the same issue: Boundary Transition. Every time sound crosses a transition between objects with differing levels of sound transparency (speed of sound through the medium), some of the sound is reflected. The ultrasound imager relies on these reflections to visualize (it's literally the principle behind ultrasound imaging), but starts to have difficulty visualizing objects beyond the transition (less transmitted signal to utilize).
For this reason, surface imperfections are to be avoided as much as possible.
So, to start, I'm going to look at biocidial, but relatively innocuous substances to make the phantoms. On the list are bleach and vinegar, added to the water.
idea - conserve the gelatin the way pickle jars are conserved
nevertheless, ultrasound works on difference between materials....unless it's gas or solid thing(bone)...you don't necessarily need gelatin for testing an ultrasound.banana in a water/cream will do.
Thanks for setting up this project. By chance are there some tips to make heart and lung phantoms for training with a A-mode ultrasound? It would be fantastic if it included phantoms for COPD and heart failure.
I used to make gelatin ultrasound phantoms. A few differences from your approach:
1) I used boric acid as an antifungal agent. Took a few weeks before mold grew on the phantoms. I don't remember the exact concentration.
2) I siphoned the mixed liquid gelatin into the molds to eliminate the froth on top. I just used very flexible PVC tubing; this would also cool the gelatin as it went into the mold.
3) I think I used way more powdered gelatin but as I don't have the recipe I can't say for sure.
Awesome feedback, and quite surprising! I stalked you a bit and couldn't find a reference to ultrasounds... where did that happen? Interested in joining this start of a project? =)
Really long day. Thanks tons for getting this set up. Also, thanks for doing better in English than I did in French (I tried. I'm the only one in my family that isn't fluent...) OK, I'm going to hit the store and start getting gelatin. The trick is going to be finding the right combination of gelatin and bacterial growth inhibitor. Along the way we'll find techniques for various inclusions (Penrose drains for veins, grapes for "tumors", etc). I need to find an ultrasound system down here that I can test on. I'll go back and talk to the hospital. What I need from the community (you folks!) is feature requests, bug reports, etc. How deep of a phantom do you need?
idea - conserve the gelatin the way pickle jars are conserved
nevertheless, ultrasound works on difference between materials....unless it's gas or solid thing(bone)...you don't necessarily need gelatin for testing an ultrasound.banana in a water/cream will do.