Close
0%
0%

Inductor Saturation Current Tester

Determining the saturation current for datasheetless, Chinese inductors.

Similar projects worth following
When designing a PT4115 based LED driver to replace some broken ones on a couple of floor lamps I have, I needed 68-100uH inductors that could handle at least 1.5A. While I had several types of inductors in this inductance range, they were from Aliexpress, so I had no datasheet. I ordered some Bourn inductors with a datasheet, so I knew they would work in this current range, but I decided I should figure out what the current handling capabilities of my Chinese inductors really were.

Meaning of Saturation Current

The current handling capability of these inductors is not dictated by the max current the coils of wire can take before getting too hot, but by the max magnetic field the core of the inductor can support. For ferrite core inductors (the most common core type), as current through the inductor increases, the magnetic field increases, and the magnetic domains in the core start to align with the magnetic field of the coil, increasing the energy the inductor can store. Once the current through the inductor increases to the point where all the domains in the core are aligned, the “enhancement” in energy storage caused by the core stops, and the effective inductance of the inductor drops. This can be seen at the elbow of the curve, and operating circuits like switch mode power supplies, or LED drivers above the saturation current will result in lower efficiency and more heating.

PCB Design

Inductance Tester PCB
Inductance Tester PCB

After Googling around a bit to get some guidance on measuring inductor saturation current, I ran across this thread, https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/inductor-saturation-tester-alternative-route-to-dump-the-excess-energy/ Subsidiary Threads: https://www.eevblog.com/forum/beginners/help-with-testing-inductor-saturation-current/, describing a circuit to do just that. I breadboarded it up, and it worked fairly well, but I decided to get a PCB made to reduce the parasitics of the breadboard. While I breadboarded up the circuit using discrete transistors, along with the Digikey order for my well characterized inductors, I also ordered some DGD0215 MOSFET gate drivers. Since it takes about 2 weeks for the PCBs to get here from China, I drew up the PCB with both the discrete transistor MOSFET driver circuit and the DGD0215 drivers. In the case that I didn’t use the DGD0215 drivers correctly in the circuit, I could fall back to the discrete transistors without having to spin up a new board and wait for the slow boat from China for a new PCB. I also added footprints for extra capacitance to supply the turn-on current surge that I didn’t need, as well as a 12 volt regulator to supply the drivers from a higher voltage for the device under test. In the end I just used 2 bench supplies; one at 12 volts for the MOSFET drivers, and one at 12-20V to test the inductors. I also put in many test points spaced for an oscilloscope probe with a ground spring, to make debugging and measuring easier. Since adding all the extra pads is free, but getting a new board takes 2 weeks, I often try to think of what could go wrong and create alternatives for that situation as well as copious test points into the PCB.

Test Point
Using a test point with a low inductance ground

If I were to create a second version of the PCB, I would remove a lot of these extra pads, as well as shortening the current loop which drives the current through the test inductor. The high current loop in this design runs around the outside of the PCB, increasing the parasitic capacitance and inductance, and hence the ringing seen in the traces, as well as increasing the EMI radiated from this device. This PCB was focused on functionality, but it works well enough that I will probably not bother to create a better one.

Hook-up
The connections to the PCB

Circuit Function

The full schematic of the board is in the project gallery, but above is the functional schematic of the populated parts. The test power is connected to J1 and 12V to drive the gates is connected to J2. The Function Generator is fed into J12, and the current is measured by the Oscilloscope probe at J16. The various Test Points are scattered about, but the second channel (green) of the scope is connected to TP1. The set of grounds at the lower right are just the ground holes for the Test Points. The inductor under test is connected to J3 DUT.

The 5V pulse from the function generator drives the DGD0215. The DGD0215 inverts the signal, so that, when the pulse is high, the output is...

Read more »

  • The Inductor Data

    Kevin Kessler01/18/2024 at 21:12 0 comments

    This is my collected data from Aliexpress inductors I have in my parts bin. The link displays the oscilloscope screen shot for that inductor test.

    The worst inductors where the SMD 1210 sized inductors, which probably were not meant for switching power applications. The best inductors were labeled Molded Power Inductors, and the saturation current measurements were really rough, since the current was so high, the voltage drop across the P-Channel FET becomes an issue. These "molded inductors" curves looks a lot like the metal alloy Bourn ones I got from Digikey, so they are probably the best choice for the power applications.

    Inductor Name
    PictureResults
    CDRH74R
    7.3mm x 7.3mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    2.2uH2.5uH14.25A
    10uH9.5uH5.2A
    47uH49.8uH5.2A
    100uH85uH1.5A
    Through Hole
    4mm x 6mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    47uH41uH14.25A
    Through Hole
    8mm x 10mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    330uH225uH190mA
    Axial
    Through Hole
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    10uH7.3uH2.25A
    47uH46.4uH944mA
    100uH93,5uH300mA
    SMD
    3.5mm x 3.5mm

    1mH released the magic smoke. Apparently the maximum current this device can handle is less than the saturation current.
    CD43
    4mm x
    4.3mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    1uH1.1uH19A
    10uH10uH3.7A
    47uH49uH1.27A
    100uH80uH0.9A
    330uH364uH380mA
    SMD 1210 2.5mm x
    3.75mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    10uH3.08uH2.3A
    100uH37uH493mA
    0402 Molded Power Inductor
    4mm x 4.5mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    10uH5.0uH17.6A
    0520 Molded Power Inductor
    5.5mm x 5.0mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    10uH7.9uH11.1A
    0650 Molded Power Inductor
    6.5mm x 6.5mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    4.7uH3.7uH25.8A
    47uH33.9uH6.75A
    1040 Molded Power Inductor
    10mm x 10.4mm
    ValueMeasured LSat I
    10uH11.3uH24.9A
    100uH81.6uH6.6A

View project log

Enjoy this project?

Share

Discussions

Similar Projects

Does this project spark your interest?

Become a member to follow this project and never miss any updates