Close
0%
0%

Wood Burner

A simple wood burning tool.

Similar projects worth following
328 views
Generates up to 20A of current to heat nichrome tip for pyrographic or wood carving/burning.

This project is a bit out of my wheelhouse. I recently attended the Rocky Mountain Woodturners Symposium, in Loveland, CO, USA. One of the demonstrators was showing how to create items that appeared to be baskets even though they are made of wood. I had already spent a small fortune on beading tools for the wood lathe and did not want to invest any more into the project. The wood burner that the demonstrator recommended was made by Razortip (>$130 for the power source), or Prescribed Burn II ($650 for a burner and micro-motor carver).

Besides, I convinced myself that it couldn't be that difficult to just heat up a piece of wire. But the trick is to just heat up a single short piece of wire and not all of the other wires involved. I bought a length of 18AWG (1mm diameter) 80/20 nichrome wire to use for experiments and also to make tips going forward. After reading about nichrome wire and performing a couple simple experiments I determined that the wood burner will need to generate between 10A and 15A of current through the nichrome tip in order to heat the tip between 400C and 1000C.

Others Have Tried and Succeeded:

I did not check the internet for evidence that this problem had been solved previously. It has. If you Google "Pyrograph Schematic" it returns a bunch of stuff, with a relatively few relevant sites or nonexistent webpages. But here's a good alternative:

This is pretty straightforward -- a power transformer connected to either 120VAC or 240VAC with a secondary output of either 1.25VAC/20A or 2.5VAC/10A, depending upon how it is connected. It even sports a power indicator! The author recommends connecting it for 1.25V/20A. A look at the data sheet shows that the input/output is specified as 115V/1.25V. If 125VAC is applied to the primary then you can expect the secondary to output 1.359VAC. This will apply a bit over 12A to 20AWG (80mR) nichrome wire tip (along with the leads to the handpiece: another 30mR). That's enough current to get the tip to a temperature around 800C, glowing a nice red. You can purchase these transformers from various electronic supply houses for around $17/each.

There is another approach that requires a bit more electronics knowledge:

This one doesn't supply a part number for the transformer, but it is essentially the same thing. The dimmer block is now broken out as a Triac controlled by a potentiometer. I looked for a 60Hz power transformer at Digikey, but did not find anything with the required current capability.

I was not aware of any of these simple schemes, so I just plowed ahead with my own concepts.

The Schematic (as of 2024/12/12):

When power is applied, the converter is held in reset by U1B for a few ms in order to let the power supply (6VDC/6A) stabilize. The NE555 generates a 200ns pulse approximately every 30us which sets the R-S latch and turns on the top PFET (M3). This causes the current to increase in the inductor, L1. This current develops a voltage across the 25mR parallel resistors, R1-2 and R7-8, which is then amplified 20x by U2. When the output voltage of U2 exceeds the set point voltage controlled by RV2 (and the user) then the comparator, U3, trips and causes the R-S latch to reset. The R-S latch is then reset, M1 is turned on, and the current in L1 decreases until the cycle repeats with another pulse from the NE555. I'm not planning to have any heatsinks. The power dissipation when applying 15A to the handpiece is less than 3W, which should be acceptable.

The gates U5C, U5D, U4C, U4D prevent shoot-through currents between M3 and M1. The huge 1000uF electrolytic capacitors have very low ESR (26mR) and are there to absorb the 15A peak currents to make it easier for the 5VDC power source to keep up.

I found a relatively cheap 5VDC/6A AC/DC adapter on Amazon for around $13. I modified it to produce 6VDC @ 6A. The handpiece could be had from Amazon for about $12-$18, or a bit less from AliExpress. I printed an enclosure using Thingiverse...

Read more »

BurnerCarver3.zip

Gerber Files to create PCBs

x-zip-compressed - 56.14 kB - 12/13/2024 at 01:22

Download

  • Second Pass Success

    Bud Bennett12/13/2024 at 00:24 0 comments

    The second pass PCBs arrived around 2024-12-01. Another very long wait for OSH Park product. I desoldered all of the major active components from the first pass PCB and soldered them onto the rev2 PCBs without issue. The new big PFET and TVS diode were added along with all of the new passive components. There were no shorts between the leads of the SSOP digital parts -- amazing.

    I plugged in the hand piece with an 18AWG nichrome tip and connected the power supply set to 6VDC/6.4A. I cranked the current setting to cause 6A from the power supply and began taking temperature measurement around the PCB. The only temps that I was interested in were the two FETs and the sense resistors. All of them settled to around 40C (ambient = 14C). This was less than what I was expecting, but welcome. No heat sinks required!

    When I swapped the 18AWG tip for a 20AWG tip the supply current increased to 6.4A, which is above the rating of the AC/DC converter that I bought. The tip was glowing a brilliant red though. I thought about reducing the current setting to allow a max of 6A from the supply when using a 20AWG tip, but then I wouldn't get enough current to drive the thicker 18AWG tip to the proper temperature ( I need about 20A through the tip for that.)

    Back to the Drawing Board

    My first thought was to limit the average voltage at the tip. This could be done by adding another opamp to sense the tip voltage and reduce the current when a voltage limit was exceeded. This would require another PCB pass...ugh. I implemented this concept on LTSpice with promising results. But during the analysis of this approach I had a different thought: why not just let the power supply drop in voltage when the current exceeds 6A? I implemented this in LTSpice using a GM source as shown below:

    The power supply now is a 6A constant current source when the load exceeds 6A. This seems to work well. When the system attempts to sink more than 6A of current from the supply it drops its voltage, keeping the current constant. Since the current set point is dependent upon the supply voltage, it decreases with decreasing supply voltage. If the tip is 80mR and the circuit tries to sink 6A the supply voltage falls to around 4.75V while delivering 6A. This is nearly a perfect solution to the problem.

    Different in Practice

    I adjusted the current set point to 2.4V with a supply voltage equal to 6V, which is a peak output current = 19.2A. I then measured the supply voltage (using the 6VDC/6A AC/DC adapter as the power supply) while changing the tips from 16AWG to 20AWG. The supply held steady at 6V, while both tips glowed a nice cherry red. I'm pretty sure that the current drawn from the supply when using the 20AWG tip exceeded 6A, but the adapter voltage did not droop.

    So I have a small dilemma: Should I just leave the circuit as is and hope that the adapter can handle the extra power dissipation without any problems, or should I change the adapter circuit to lower the current limit threshold to 6A? I chose the former. If the adapter fails due to excessive current or power dissipation then I'll have to purchase another one and try to alter the circuit to lower the current limit. Until then...no harm, no foul.

  • First Prototype Evaluation

    Bud Bennett11/09/2024 at 00:07 0 comments

    It seemed to take OSH Park forever to fab these PCBs. I eventually received 3 perfect purple PCBs last Monday (2024-11-04). I populated one of them and immediately discovered a problem. M3 was wired upside down! The source and drain were reversed, so it was essentially a diode connected to the positive supply. When I powered it up the circuit hit the current limit of the power supply at about 2V. 

    After grokking the problem I set about to re-wire M3. It is almost impossible to skywire a power FET. The gate lead is so tiny and the 3 source pins don't lend themselves to easy connections. I did eventually connect a new AO7405 using 1mm wires. The circuit functioned for a while until the PFET smoked. A dangling 3.3mm x 3.3mm package probably has a 300C/W thermal resistance. Even 1W of dissipation would put it over the 170C limit of the silicon.

    Then I remembered that I had some unpopulated small PCBs that used the same footprint as the PFET. It was relatively easy to solder a new AO7405 to the bare board and connect it to the the burner PCB with a few 26 AWG wires. Here's the result:

    The circuit worked as expected after this fix. I was able to pull about 4.6A from 5VDC and get a satisfying red glow from the tip of the burner. I calculate that the circuit was generating between 12-14A across the heating element.

    At this point I decided to check the temperatures of the top PFET and bottom NFET to see if there was a problem. The bottom NFET settled out at 47C with 4A (20W) pulled from the power supply. No problem there. The top PFET was pretty hot at 97C at 20W, and maxed out at 117C with 23.5W pulled from the supply. That PFET has a RDSon ~ 10mR, which should not be a problem at these currents (15A). It is difficult to determine if the problem is that the PFET is mounted on a smallish PCB dangling in thin air, or a result of some other unforeseen issue. I decided to err on the safe side and change the design -- using a bigger PFET, both in RDSon (6mR) and package size, 5x6mm vs. 3.3x3.3mm. 

    So I dug a bit deeper. I got the oscilloscope out of storage and put a probe across the hand piece terminals to get this:

    This was taken with the 5V supply reading 2A current draw. Something is very wrong with this. The 0.5V step up and down should not be there. I thought it might be an improper ground reference of the scope, but it did not change with several other ground points. I even dug out my differential probe, which did not record any difference. 

    I decided to check what the opamp was seeing and got this trace at the opamp output:

    This is more like it, except for the spikes at the transition points. It took me a long time to figure out what is going on: mutual inductance. The handpiece has two approximately 1m long wires running to the tip and back. Those wires are separated by about 5mm. A quick trip to the mutual inductance calculator on the web produced an inductance of around 1.4uH per lead, with a mutual inductance about half of that. When I added the lead inductance and mutual inductance to my SPICE simulation it produced nearly identical results to what I was seeing on the bench.

    I modeled the handpiece and tip as a 100mR resistor with two mutually coupled inductors, and for good measure a bit of parallel capacitance. The most interesting thing to note is that the current through the handpiece is not affected, and neither is the current through L1. So the opamp output should be a nice triangle, but the glitches don't matter much in the scheme of things as long as the opamp recovers. Adding a 5pF capacitor across the feedback resistor might fix it.

    Second Pass Changes

    I found a replacement for the PFET -- a DMPH1006UPS. It has an RDSon=6mR with VAGS = 4.5V, comes in a 5x6mm power pak type of package. The downside is that the VDSmax is 12V, so I probably won't be able to use it for many other project. But the advantage there is that the total gate charge, Qg, is quite low at only 72nC, which...

    Read more »

View all 2 project logs

Enjoy this project?

Share

Discussions

Similar Projects

Does this project spark your interest?

Become a member to follow this project and never miss any updates