-
Old BLDC
3 hours ago • 0 comments![]()
This motor is screwed.
I was a bit overconfident with my screws because I used them before on this very motor. I didn't account for the thickness of the attachment that ate a good couple of millimeters from the screw length. Anyway...
A brief summary of where Tapeshnik-Mecha got somewhat stuck (some notes are kept in https://github.com/svofski/tapeshnik/blob/master/docs/FUTURISTIC.md , some are in youtubes):
* unsolvable motor cogging
* probably as simple as not enough volts, but my driver can't do more than 10
* probably SimpleFOC could do better if I specified a slightly higher coil resistanceOther possible ideas to try:
- Use bigger motors
- Use higher voltage and e.g. SimpleFOCMini 2.0 board
- Use belts. Not ideal but they would allow using the motors in their better comfort zone with higher rpm, maybe even use current sensing
- Use NEMA11 stepper motors in smooth rotation mode -- not at all an unreasonable idea
- Maybe just make a bloody capstan
Basically that's where I'm leaving it for now.
Meanwhile I have this other toy handy:
It's a language repetition device from a Chinese company named SOCO. It has rather unusual kinematics using a single motor for everything, including "logic" style function selector.
I don't think I can squeeze much out of its standard DC motor so I replaced its motor with a DVD one. It took me much longer than anticipated to get the motor going. SimpleFOC is a beautiful library but it's not always easy to start, especially when you have no idea what you're doing. At first I thought I need hall sensors together with low-side current sensing. After a while I figured out that in fact SimpleFOC supports "sensorless" spin mode. But it took me many hours to figure out the settings for it.
After all I still don't know if I did the right thing. Basically I had to lie to the library about my coil resistance, or it wouldn't work. Measured resistance is 1.9 ohm, I ended up specifying 2.1 ohm. Seems like an insignificant difference, but it matters a whole lot.
Now for my project I need to prepare a custom cassette with a stereo recording. I don't have a boombox anywhere around me. After checking out all cheap recording walkmans I learned that literally none of them record stereo. Worse even, those that record mono and have AUX input don't really even record from AUX input.. So I'm considering making my own recording implement. The only problem so far is that I don't really know how.
svofski