-
What's in your water?
09/19/2017 at 18:28 • 0 commentsStep 1: Research
The first task is to identify the common contaminants found in municipal water. A quick google search provided the following resources:
EPA's list of regulated contaminants (this is pretty large...) or the Printable version
US Geological Survey - Contaminants in Ground Water
Neilson Research Corporation - Common Drinking Water Contaminants
CDC's Top 10 Water-related Diseases and Contaminants in Public Water Systems
The following link was the top hit on Google, and also provides an abbreviated list, but I would rate the information in the "trust but verify" category.
Environmental Illness Resource - Common Chemical Contaminants of Municipal Water
This is a nice link; it allows you to search for your water system and you can find out what violations have been logged. This may help you make a decision to add some targeted filtration. My system had multiple violations of fecal coliform (last violation was 9 years ago) which may explain why we seem to have very high chlorine levels. I need to pay more attention to filtering chlorine.
EPA's SDWIS Federal Reports Search
Step 2: IdentificationWhat do we do with the plethora of information? There is obviously way too much to digest without being an expert, and the purpose of this is to get a simpler view of what exists in my water that needs attention. Another approach is to look at what people are verifying using available tests. The only way you will know if you need to filter something is to identify that substance in your water, both before and after filtration.
The following list comes from a search for "water quality test" on amazon. These are the available tests that can be done with test strips:
- Free Chlorine
- Total Chlorine
- pH
- Nitrites
- Nitrates
- Bromine
- Bacteria
- Pesticide
- Total Alkalinity
- Total Hardness
- Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)
- Iron
- Iron Bacteria
- Copper
- Lead
- Cyanuric Acid
- Hydrogen Sulfide
Step 3: Breakdown
So now that we have list of what we can test for, we can "not worry" about the other stuff. Most of the stuff we can't test for is filtered to some level with whatever filtration we choose. Now we need to put the previous list into some kind of priority order. I'm going to do this for myself, but I'll list with each item why I chose it in that position.
- Free Chlorine
- This is probably the most concerning "contaminant". I say that because this is actually added in order to control biological contamination. This is the actual chlorine that is available to treat the water. This differs from total chlorine, which is the quantity of free chlorine along with the chlorine that has already bonded with stuff and is less able to treat other contaminants.
- Chlorine is probably the number one item listed by health nuts to filter from your water, both for taste and for health reasons. It is easily absorbed through the skin as well as internally. There is quite a bit of anecdotal evidence (maybe some scientific, but I haven't actively researched yet) that various health conditions stem from absorption of chlorine.
- This is also something you want to filter at the point of use, because taking the chlorine out of your water before it sits in your hot water heater you risk growing bad biological stuff in your water heater.
- To be continued later (maybe years later... that's kind of how these things go for me...)
-
Requirements
10/29/2015 at 18:53 • 0 commentsBefore starting a project, it is key to boil down the requirements: exactly what is the point, or goal of the project. Here are the requirements for this project:
- Determine the common municipal water contaminants that consumers are worried about.
- List methods for filtering each contaminant.
- Identify filter media types and life cycles.
- Identify system flows that can increase life of media.
- Design filter housings.
- Design filter system flow for my specific need.
- Identify control methods and implimentation.
-
The Beginnings...
10/29/2015 at 18:43 • 0 commentsI was recently roped into taking a "water survey" at Home Depot for the chance to "win" a $20 gift certificate to Home Depot. I soon received a phone call to schedule a "water test" at my house in exchange for $20 Home Depot gift card. I should have known; it was a bait and switch high-pressure sales pitch for a Rainsoft whole house filtration system. Looking online, I am not alone.
After 3 hours of magic tricks involving uncalibrated equipment, inflated qualitative results, a book of statistics manipulated to look scary, a questionable economics worksheet, and offers for free soap, I declined their $8000 machine (and free soap). Now, my water has never tasted great, and although I agree it can be better, there's no evidence of real health risk. Although my $20 gift card to Home Depot is on it's way, my wife will now only drink bottled water, so the $20 on that card was paid for by empty plastic water bottles now cluttering our recycling bin. Now I see why they insist that your wife be present at the "test". But I digress...
After this ordeal, I began to look online and have discovered the following things:
- There is nothing special about the hardware required to make a bulk media style whole house water filter. You need tanks, valves, and pipes. If you want, you can make the valves electronic and add a controller.
- Other than the requirements that the EPA governs, there is no solid evidence on "safe" levels of contaminants.
- There is no information (that I have quickly found) that summarizes the common types of water contamination and the associated methods to filter it.
- Tons of people have made DIY systems, but most are just using off the shelf cartridge filters, or want you to pay for their plans. Free plans are usually for gravity or "emergency" off-grid systems.
- Commercial systems are stupid expensive.
Also, all of the parlor tricks involve only two components of water filtration:
- Chlorine - easily filtered with carbon filters - usually touted as the "scariest" health risk, and is easy to smell/taste.
- "Hardness" - No health risk, but removal or softening allows a better "feel" of the water.
I have a terrible personal track record of finishing projects, so I welcome any help from anyone who wants to contribute. I have started this project here so that my efforts to build my own personal system and understand how filtration works can be beneficial to others. I don't have a timeline, except to build a filter before my wife fills the house with empty water bottles. Having said that, don't be afraid to poke me with a comment if there's no movement in a while.